Skip to main content
  • International Sites
    • International
    • Australia
    • Brazil
    • Canada
    • China
    • CHINA (ENGLISH)
    • France
    • Germany
    • Hong Kong
    • India
    • Japan
    • JAPAN (ENGLISH)
    • Korea
    • Korea (ENGLISH)
    • Mexico
    • Russia
    • Southeast Asia
    • United Kingdom
  • Magazines
    • Art+Auction

      Modern Painters

  • Blogs
  • Videos
  • Photos
  • Art Prices
  • Gallery Guide
  • Art Sites
  • Boutique
  • Blouin News
  • Log in

    Log in

    |Forgot your password?
    OR
    Sign up

    Not a member?

    Create an Account
Home
  • Visual Arts
    • Visual Arts Home
    • Contemporary Art
    • Old Masters/Renaissance
    • Impressionism & Modern Art
    • Ancient Arts & Antiques
    • Traditional Arts
    • Museums
    • Reviews
    • Columnists
    • Fairs
    • Features
  • Performing Arts
    • Performing Arts Home
    • Film
    • Music
    • Theater & Dance
    • Television
    • Events
    • Blogs
    • Photos
    • Videos
  • Architecture & Design
    • Architecture & Design Home
    • Design
    • Architecture
  • Artists
  • Art Prices
  • Market News
    • Market News Home
    • Fairs
    • Auctions
    • Collecting
    • Galleries
    • Art & Crime
    • ART PRICES
  • Lifestyle
    • Lifestyle Home
    • ART Parties/Scene
    • Fashion
    • Food & Wine
    • Jewelry & Watches
    • Autos & Boats
  • Fashion
  • Events
  • Travel
  • Newsletter Sign Up
  • Homepage RSS
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • foursquare
  • tumblr
 
International Edition
June 19, 2013 Last Updated: 4:28:PM EDT

Jennifer Dalton on the "Having It All" Debate

English

Jennifer Dalton on the "Having It All" Debate

  • Email
  • Print
  • Tweet
  • Pin It
Photo © Micah Schmidt
Jennifer Dalton
by Jennifer Dalton
Published: July 19, 2012

First of all, as others have pointed out (in particular, the brilliant Rebecca Traister at Salon), "having it all" is an offensive way to frame the problem. No one gets to have it all; using that phrase makes legitimate feminist goals of equal opportunity seem childish, absurd, and materialistic. What people generally want, and are right to expect, is a not-horrifyingly-unequal shot at success and happiness.

As has also been widely noted, Anne-Marie Slaughter speaks from, and largely to, the vantage point of upper-middle-class white privilege. To her credit she takes the rare step of acknowledging this, and I think her arguments are important to bear out despite this limitation. If we want more women leaders in politics, business, and science, Slaughter's problems are part of understanding the barriers to achieving that. So yes, she is in an enviable position of having choices that most women don't have; but if we want more than 17 percent women in Congress, if we want women running more than 3.6 percent of Fortune 500 companies, if we ever want to see a woman U.S. president, the choices of women at the top have an effect on all of us.

 

What I don't like is her framing of women's choices as more fraught than men's because women inherently feel less comfortable working and spending time away from their children than men do. I respect that this has been her experience, but I haven't found it to be generally true for me or the other parents I know. I would argue that there is a vicious cycle perpetuating more women than men staying home as primary caregivers and thus taking a slower career track or opting out entirely: Statistically women still earn less money than men and when push comes to shove many women find it "just makes more financial sense" for them to quit working rather than pay for child care. Adding to this pressure on women's choices is the still-true fact, surprisingly ignored by Slaughter, that women put in a national average of between 6 and 12 more weekly hours of housework and childcare than men do, even when both partners both work full time. This is an added tax on women's ambition — we could call it the exhaustion tax. It is not just workplace culture that needs to change in order for women to have an equal shot at success. I think that this home imbalance is even more difficult to overcome.  

The art world exists within the larger culture and has the same problems, as I and others have chronicled repeatedly. It may be an easier place for women to balance work and family, since artists (at least successful ones!) have control over their schedule. But one has to actually get successful for that to happen, and based on the numbers that seems to be much harder for women artists.

In 2006 I did a survey work called “How Do Artists Live?” Almost 900 artists gave anonymous responses to questions about their income and lifestyle. Among other things, I asked if the responding artists had kids, and I asked if they had gallery representation. Among those responding the male artists with kids had the highest percentage (approximately 50 percent) of gallery representation. Female artists with kids had the lowest percentage (approximately 20 percent). Male artists with kids and female artists without them were about tied, about 27-28 percent with gallery representation.

Share This Story

  • Tweet This

  • Post to Stumble Upon
  • Email to a Friend
Go to top ↑
by Jennifer Dalton,Art & Politics
Share:
  • Tweet
  • Email to a Friend

Comments

0 Comments
+ Add Yours
Log in or register to post comments
Oldest first Newest first

Most Popular

  • This Week
  • This Month
  • This Year
  • Why is French Artist Orlan Suing Lady Gaga?
  • How Contemporary Art Came to Dominate the Auctions
  • 30 New York City Art Spaces Worth Discovering
  • Kandinsky's $21-Mil Rider Leads Christie's Sale
  • Thoughts on Kanye West’s "Yeezus"
  • CHECKLIST: LACMA to Fete Scorsese, and More
  • 25 Questions for "Future Feminist" Art Icon Antony
  • Major Bertoia Sale Leads Spring Design Auctions
  • The 50 Next Most Collectible Artists, Part 1
  • Top 10 Booths at Art Basel in Hong Kong 2013
  • The 50 Next Most Collectible Artists, Part 2
  • Damien Hirst, Others, Invest $6 Mil in Paddle8
  • Warhol Foundation Head Joel Wachs's Pop Art Empire
  • See 10 Pavilions From the 55th Venice Biennale
  • On the "International Art English" Debate
  • Is the Art Market Becoming a Supply-Side Economy?
  • The 100 Most Iconic Artworks of the Last 5 Years
  • The 50 Most Exciting Art Collectors Under 50 (Part 1)
  • Back to School Guide: The 10 MFA Programs That Give You the Most Bang For Your Buck
  • Basquiat's Ex-Girlfriend Reveals Major Trove of Unseen Works
  • Facebook Censors Pompidou's Gerhard Richter Nude, Fueling Fight Over "Institutional Puritanism"

Popular on Facebook

Editorial

  • Visual Arts
  • Performing Arts
  • Architecture & Design
  • Artists
  • Art Prices
  • Market News
  • Lifestyle
  • Fashion
  • Events
  • Travel

Products

  • Magazines
  • Gallery Guide
  • Blouin Art Sales Index
  • Somogy
  • Art Sites
  • Art Jobs

Louise Blouin Media

  • About Us
  • Subscriptions
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Louise Blouin Foundation
  • RSS
Copyright © 2013 All rights reserved. Use of the site constitutes agreement with our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.